Mystery Movie Review - Copycat

 Copycat 1995.  Per usual, this movie did well so Hollywood threw together a sequel that did so poorly you can barely find it mentioned.  Which is fine.  Let this movie stand on its own.  This is one of those rarities that was never a book first.  

What it's about:  A criminal psychologist who became agoraphobic (afraid to leave the house) after a murder attempt agrees to help two San Francisco detectives hunt for a copycat serial killer who intends on making her his next victim.

Tagline:  One man is copying the most notorious killers in history one at a time. Together, two women must stop him from killing again. Or they're next.

Rated R for violence and language

Filmed in San Francisco CA

Cast:

Sigourney Weaver as Helen Hudson

Holly Hunter as MJ Monahan

Dermot Mulroney as Ruben Goetz

William McNamara as Peter Foley

Harry Connick Jr. as Daryll Lee Cullum

J.E. Freeman as Lt. Quinn

Will Patton as Nicoletti

Director: Jon Amiel

Writers: Ann BidermanDavid Madsen

Rotten Tomatoes (76%) and critics reviews:

• "Copycat is a well-paced thriller, adroit, compelling, and slick."  Barbara Shulgasser - Common Sense Media

• "It's one of the better thrillers of the 1990s." Dennis Schwartz of Dennis Schwartz Movie Reviews

• "What raises Copycat marginally above the second-rate and impotent is director Jon Amiel."  Peter Keough of Boston Phoenix

• "Although the plotting of this mystery-thriller about a copycat killer is flawed, Hunter and Weaver drive the show with strong performances."  Jeff Strickler of Minneapolis Star Tribune

• "A straightforward intelligent thriller."  Steven Rea of Philadelphia Inquirer

• "A serial killer drama that stands above the rest of the copycats."  Malcolm Johnson of Hartford Courant

• "Killer star power propels Copycat."  Steve Murray of Atlanta Journal-Constitution

• "A grade B thriller with a grade A cast, and this time the cast makes all the difference."  Rene Rodriguez of Miami Herald

Noteworthy awards or rankings:

-- 1996 Winner of Special Mention by Sigourney Weaver & Holly Hunter 

Cognac Festival du Film Policier

-- 1996 Winner Audience Award Director Jon Amiel 

Cognac Festival du Film Policier

-- 1996 Nominee Saturn Award for Best Music from

Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Films, USA

-- Included among the American Film Institute's 2001 list of 400 movies nominated for the top 100 Most Heart-Pounding American Movies.

Trivia (mostly from IMDB):

-- Years later, Sigourney Weaver would state that she was most proud of her work in this film. She worked hard to portray the mindset of an agoraphobic, and has regretted that the movie was lost in a shuffle of thrillers at the time and is not better remembered.

-- To research her role, Sigourney Weaver consulted with leading forensic psychiatrist Park Dietz, who had interviewed serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer.

-- Harry Connick Jr. spent weeks watching documentaries on serial killers in preparation for his role.

-- Sigourney Weaver is almost a foot taller than Holly Hunter, thus for many scenes Weaver would be sitting down to make their heights appear more equal.

-- The climactic bathroom scene took 8 days to film.

-- William McNamara spoke to the Happy Horror Time Podcast and told them his character was entirely re-written and re-shot after failed screen tests deemed him the worst part of the movie, calling his character "too cerebral". The rewrite was done by Frank Darabont and McNamara was coached by Anthony Hopkins for his re-shoots.

-- Holly Hunter hung out with several homicide detectives in downtown L.A. to help her get into character.

-- James Newton Howard was approached to score the film, but turned it down to work on Waterworld (1995) instead. Christopher Young replaced him, and director Jon Amiel was so happy with the result, he renewed his collaboration with Young on several other films.

-- In each appearance, Holly Hunter has a different hairstyle.

-- When Sigourney Weaver lures the serial killer to come to her, she whispers "kitty, kitty, kitty". Those are the same words she whispered in the classic sci-fi epic "Alien", when she was looking for her real cat, but instead the alien monster appeared. Some piano chords in the final credit soundtrack resemble the same chords as in "Alien".

-- (at around 24 mins) The captain says to MJ that he had worked the Zodiac case. Dermot Mulroney (Ruben) later played a captain in the movie Zodiac (2007).

My Thoughts:

This is one of those movies that you remember years after seeing it.  The cast makes this movie shine. Sigourney Weaver is at the top of her acting in this movie.  Forget Alien, give me this movie for her abilities as an actress.  I must mention Harry Connick Jr playing a ruthless killer who has a cult following - he is scary believable.  A bit too believable.  I've never looked at him the same since, it was so well done.  And Holly Hunter was great in this as the police detective. 

The movie kept me glued to it and the suspense builds like a classic Hitchcock.  Is it perfect, no.  But it is a great bit of suspense and does its job of entertaining and taking the audience on a ride.  It has 1995 computers and is a bit nostalgic in that regard.  Revisit this classic thriller  for its straightforward storytelling and edge of your seat killer confrontation.

Movie Trailer:

Thank you for reading this blog and please recommend to friends and family who will enjoy it.

Join my author newsletter, get a recipe booklet for subscribing: Click Here